Do You Need an External Evaluator? If You’re Applying for These Grants, Yes.

TL;DR

Some federal and philanthropic grants require or strongly encourage the use of an external evaluator to measure outcomes, report impact, and support compliance. If you’re applying for programs from the DOE, NSF, DOL, or foundations like RWJF, plan to bring an evaluator to the table early.

Not All Evaluators Are Created Equal—Some Must Be External

Let’s be real. Grant funding is competitive, and requirements are only getting tighter. Evaluation isn’t just a “nice to have” anymore. For many high-profile grant programs, external evaluation is non-negotiable. That means not your cousin with a clipboard or your project manager “doubling up.” We’re talking trained, third-party professionals who bring credibility, objectivity, and rigorous methodology to the outcomes party.

If you’re gearing up for one of these grants, skip the guesswork—you will need an external evaluator.

What Kind of Grants Are We Talking About?

Here’s a non-exhaustive list of programs that call for independent evaluation, either as a requirement or a scoring booster:

📘 Department of Education (ED)

  • Programs: EIR, i3, GEAR UP, TRIO
  • Why: Evaluation must meet WWC standards and often includes a randomized or quasi-experimental design. You won’t get far without an outside expert.

🔬 National Science Foundation (NSF)

  • Programs: ADVANCE, I-Corps, INCLUDES, S-STEM
  • Why: These programs want data-backed impact. An evaluator provides the rigor NSF loves to see.

🧠 National Institutes of Health (NIH)

  • Programs: SBIR Fast Track, CRP
  • Why: Especially in public health or clinical areas, NIH expects robust outcomes tracking. That means calling in an outsider with relevant evaluation chops.

⚙️ U.S. Department of Labor (DOL)

  • Programs: YouthBuild, Apprenticeship Building America, WIOA grants
  • Why: Performance accountability is king. Most DOL funding comes with explicit or implicit mandates for third-party evaluation.

💼 Department of Energy (DOE) & ARPA-E

  • Programs: Demonstration pilots, energy innovation, ARPA-E
  • Why: You’re trying to prove economic or environmental impact? They want a neutral evaluator to back it up.

📈 Economic Development Administration (EDA)

  • Programs: Build to Scale, Recompete, Tech Hubs, Good Jobs Challenge
  • Why: Regional development grants want hard evidence that your job creation stats aren’t just… optimistic math.

💡 Major Foundations

  • Examples: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, Kellogg Foundation, Annie E. Casey Foundation
  • Why: These funders love data. Their money comes with an expectation of storytelling through validated results.

Why You Actually Want One (Even If It’s Not Required)

Sure, external evaluation is sometimes a box to check. But it’s also a strategic move. Evaluators:

  • Help you track real-world impact
  • Increase your credibility with funders
  • Support future funding renewals
  • Offer insights that improve your program on the fly
  • Keep you compliant with federal reporting standards

In short: They make your project look good and actually perform better.

What Happens If You Skip It?

You might think, “We’ll do the evaluation ourselves.” But if a funding agency explicitly requires a third-party evaluator, going internal means disqualification. Period. Even if it’s not mandated, proposals with independent evaluators often score higher because they show foresight, accountability, and professionalism.

No evaluator? No dice.

Plan Early and Choose Wisely

Your evaluator isn’t just a vendor—they’re a key partner. Start scouting for one before the proposal is due. Bonus points if they’ve worked with your target agency before and know how to talk metrics that matter. Better yet, talk to us.

At E.B. Howard Consulting has served as the external evaluation team for high-stakes projects across education, health, workforce, energy, and economic development. We know the language, the logic model, and the reporting formats funders expect.

Need an Evaluator? We’re on Deck.

If your upcoming proposal needs an external evaluation plan—or if you’re not sure if it does—let’s talk. We’ve helped clients land millions in competitive funding, and our evaluation services are both credible and cost-effective.

Ready To Take the Next Step?

Schedule a Consult Call

We assist our clients in locating, applying for, and evaluating the outcomes of non-dilutive grant funding. We believe non-dilutive funding is a crucial tool for mitigating investment risks, and we are dedicated to guiding our clients through the entire process—from identifying the most suitable opportunities to submitting and managing grant applications.