For innovators and small businesses navigating government funding opportunities, understanding Technology Readiness Levels (TRLs) is critical. These levels serve as a standardized framework to assess and communicate the maturity of a technology, from concept to deployment. Knowing how to use TRLs effectively can make the difference between a successful funding proposal and one that falls short.
Technology Readiness Levels (TRLs) are a standardized measure used to assess the maturity of a technology, from its initial concept to its readiness for deployment in the market. TRLs are important in the context of Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) and Small Business Technology Transfer (STTR) programs because these programs often fund the development of innovative technologies that can be commercialized. The TRL scale helps the funding agencies assess the progress of a technology at various stages, ensuring that the business is working towards achievable milestones and is capable of meeting the program’s objectives.
What Are TRLs?
Technology Readiness Levels are a nine-point scale developed by NASA and widely adopted across industries, including defense, energy, and education. They measure the development progress of a technology, ensuring that it aligns with the expectations and goals of funding programs or stakeholders.
Here’s how TRLs are relevant to SBIR/STTR:
- Evaluation of Technology Maturity: SBIR and STTR programs are structured in phases that correspond to increasing levels of technology development:
- Phase I: Proof of concept (TRL 1-3) – Focuses on feasibility, with the goal of demonstrating that the technology can work in principle.
- Phase II: Prototype development and demonstration (TRL 4-6) – Involves creating a working prototype and demonstrating its capabilities in relevant environments.
- Phase III: Commercialization (TRL 7-9) – Aiming for the final commercial product, with technology fully integrated and market-ready.
- Risk Mitigation: Funding agencies use TRLs to gauge the risks associated with funding the development of a technology. Technologies at lower TRLs (1-3) are typically considered more risky since they are still in the research or conceptual stages. On the other hand, technologies that are at higher TRLs (7-9) are closer to commercialization and present a lower risk for potential investors and government agencies.
- Guiding Proposal Development: For SBIR/STTR applicants, understanding TRLs is crucial when developing proposals. The applicant needs to clearly define the current TRL of their technology and specify the steps they will take to advance it during the project. Being able to demonstrate how the technology will progress through the TRLs during the funded phases can strengthen the proposal and show the likelihood of success.
- Phase Advancement Criteria: In both SBIR and STTR, advancing from one phase to the next often requires evidence that certain milestones have been met, including achieving specific TRLs. This makes TRLs an integral part of tracking progress and ensuring that the technology is ready for commercialization by the time the project moves from Phase II to Phase III.
In summary, TRLs help align the objectives of SBIR/STTR with realistic technological development expectations, providing both the government and the businesses involved with a structured framework to assess progress and de-risk the path to commercialization.
Examples of TRL Application
- SBIR/STTR Programs: Many agencies require technologies at TRL 3–4 for feasibility studies (Phase I) and TRL 5–6 for prototype development (Phase II).
- Commercialization Planning: Investors and partners often look for technologies at TRL 7 or higher, indicating readiness for market adoption.
TRLs are more than a technical checklist—they’re a strategic tool for innovation. By understanding and leveraging the TRL framework, you can position your technology for funding, development, and ultimate success in the marketplace. Whether you’re building the next groundbreaking AI system or developing advanced materials for defense, TRLs provide the clarity and structure needed to navigate the complex path of innovation.
Ready To Take the Next Step?
We assist our clients in locating, applying for, and evaluating the outcomes of non-dilutive grant funding. We believe non-dilutive funding is a crucial tool for mitigating investment risks, and we are dedicated to guiding our clients through the entire process—from identifying the most suitable opportunities to submitting and managing grant applications.